1.51 CT Emerald-Cut Diamond 3 Stone Engagement Ring, 18K White Gold

She told you the tie didn't work, first date, straight out. Not unkind. She just doesn't see the point in saying something she doesn't mean.

That's the woman about to wear this ring every day, so you don't want a diamond that's trying to fool anyone. An emerald cut is set in wide, flat steps, not the little chopped-up facets that scatter light so you can't quite see through a stone. What's inside is right there, plain as anything, about a carat and a half of it. Two trapezoid diamonds flank it, cut on the same angle, holding the line instead of throwing sparkle around to distract you.

A 1.51-carat emerald-cut diamond sits at the center, I color, SI2 clarity. Two trapezoid-cut diamonds flank it, 0.45 carat total weight. The setting is polished 18-karat white gold.

She's never faked a compliment. The diamond isn't faking anything either.

• Center stone: one emerald-cut diamond, approx. 1.51 ct, I color, SI2 clarity
• Side stones: two trapezoid diamonds, 0.45 ct total weight
• Metal: 18-karat white gold, polished
• Setting: three-stone
• Warranty: covered by the Greatest Warranty On The Planet.